Class pack · 9.4 Thermodynamic and kinetic control
One page for students, then the answer key on its own page. Free to print and share.
AP Chemistry · Unit 9: Thermodynamics and Electrochemistry

9.4 Thermodynamic and kinetic control

Name: ______________________   Class: ________   Date: ________
Scan to try 3 questions on your phone
The big idea.

A thermodynamically favorable reaction (ΔG∘<0\Delta G^\circ < 0) may still occur too slowly to observe if its activation energy is high; such a reaction is under kinetic control. Thermodynamics tells whether products are favored, while kinetics tells how fast they form. For example, C(s,diamond)→C(s,graphite)\ce{C(s, diamond) -> C(s, graphite)} has ΔG∘<0\Delta G^\circ < 0, but diamond does not noticeably change because the activation energy is very large.

The lesson (about 15 minutes)

  1. Explore the simulation: ΔG against temperature. https://apchemistrytutoring.com/units/9/9-4-thermodynamic-and-kinetic-control/#sim-gibbs
  2. Answer the 5 questions below on your own (about 8 minutes).
  3. Check with the answer key, then scan the QR code for 3 more questions with instant feedback.

Questions

1. The conversion of diamond to graphite is thermodynamically favorable at room temperature, yet diamonds do not visibly change. Why?

  1. The activation energy is so high that the reaction is extremely slow.
  2. ΔG\Delta G for the conversion is positive.
  3. The reaction has reached equilibrium.
  4. The entropy of the universe would decrease.

2. A reaction has ΔH° = −160 kJ/mol_rxn and ΔS° = +600 J/(mol_rxn·K). What can be concluded about the reaction at 200 K?

  1. It is fast.
  2. It is slow.
  3. It is thermodynamically favored, but its rate cannot be predicted from these data.
  4. It is not thermodynamically favored.

3. Natural gas (CH₄) leaks into a room full of air. The combustion of methane is strongly thermodynamically favored, yet no reaction occurs until a light switch sparks. Which best explains this?

  1. The concentration of methane is too low for the reaction to be favored.
  2. The reaction is at equilibrium before the spark.
  3. The activation energy is high, so at room temperature almost no collisions have enough energy to react.
  4. The spark makes ΔG° negative.

4. Which statement about a catalyst added to a thermodynamically favored reaction is correct?

  1. It makes ΔG° more negative.
  2. It increases K.
  3. It lowers the activation energy and does not change ΔG°.
  4. It changes the reaction from endothermic to exothermic.

5. A sealed flask contains a mixture of H₂(g) and O₂(g) at 25 °C. After a year, no water has formed, although ΔG° for 2 H₂(g) + O₂(g) → 2 H₂O(l) is −474 kJ/mol_rxn. Which statement is correct?

  1. The mixture is at equilibrium.
  2. The reaction is thermodynamically unfavored at 25 °C.
  3. The reaction is under kinetic control.
  4. The reaction would be favored only with a catalyst.

From AP Chemistry Tutoring: the full lesson, more practice and the simulation at https://apchemistrytutoring.com/units/9/9-4-thermodynamic-and-kinetic-control/

Answer key · 9.4 Thermodynamic and kinetic control

  1. A. Favorable does not mean fast. The process is under kinetic control: a very large activation energy keeps the rate negligible.
  2. C. ΔG° = −160 − (200)(0.600) = −280 kJ/mol_rxn, so it is favored. Rate depends on activation energy, which these thermodynamic data do not give.
  3. C. The reaction is under kinetic control. The mixture is far from equilibrium, not at it. The spark supplies activation energy; it does not change ΔG°.
  4. C. A catalyst provides an alternative pathway with lower Ea. ΔG°, ΔH°, ΔS° and K depend only on the initial and final states, so they do not change.
  5. C. ΔG° is very negative, so the reaction is favored and K is huge. Because no product forms, the system is far from equilibrium and is limited by a high activation energy.

Students can try 3 more questions with instant feedback at https://apchemistrytutoring.com/start/9/?topic=9.4&n=3&utm_source=class&utm_medium=print&utm_campaign=9.4

Chat on WhatsApp