2.6 Resonance and formal charge
AP Chemistry Unit 2: Compound Structure and Properties · 17 practice questions
Updated · Aligned to the AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description
Resonance occurs when more than one valid Lewis diagram can be drawn for a species; the real structure is an average (hybrid), so equivalent bonds have identical lengths. Formal charge, (valence electrons minus nonbonding electrons minus half the bonding electrons), helps choose the best Lewis diagram: formal charges closest to zero, with any negative charge on the most electronegative atom.
Formal charge & resonance
When more than one diagram works, compare formal charges.
All zeros beats +1 / −1.
If a −1 can't be avoided, put it on N rather than S.
: four P–O single bonds, or one P=O double bond and three singles?
- All singles: P . Each O .
- One double: P . The double-bonded O .
- The other three O are −1 in both, so compare only P and that one O.
- The P=O structure has charges closer to zero. (P is in period 3, so it can hold 10 electrons.)
: S–C≡N or S=C=N?
- S–C≡N: S , C , N .
- S=C=N: S , C , N .
- Both have one −1, so rule 1 is a tie.
- N is more electronegative than S, so S=C=N (−1 on N) is better.
Resonance: the real molecule is an average.
can put its double bond on either side. Neither picture is real. Both O–O bonds are actually identical, in between a single and a double bond.
Try and in the builder above and press "Next resonance structure".
?O=C=O or O≡C–O: which Lewis diagram of is better?Think, then tap to check
O=C=O: every atom has formal charge 0. In O≡C–O the oxygens are +1 and −1.
Study notes
Key concepts
Resonance (SAP-4.B.1). Sometimes two or more equally valid Lewis diagrams can be drawn for the same arrangement of atoms. They differ only in where the electrons (multiple bonds and lone pairs) are placed, never in where the atoms are. Each one is a resonance structure, and they are joined by a double-headed arrow (↔).
The real molecule is not switching between the structures. It has one fixed electron distribution, called the resonance hybrid, that is an average of the structures. The electrons in the multiple bonds are delocalized over several atoms instead of being fixed between one pair of atoms.
Ozone, O₃, is the classic case. You can draw O=O–O or O–O=O (with the double bond on either side). Each single Lewis structure predicts one long bond and one short bond, but experiments show both O–O bonds in ozone are the same length (128 pm), between a typical O–O single bond (148 pm) and the O=O double bond in O₂ (121 pm). Only the resonance picture predicts this correctly. That is why the CED says resonance is "needed to provide qualitatively accurate predictions of molecular structure and properties".
Bond order in resonance structures. For a set of equivalent bonds:
| Species | Resonance structures | Equivalent bonds | Bond order | Consequence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| O₃ | 2 | 2 O–O | 3/2 = 1.5 | both O–O bonds equal, between single and double |
| NO₂⁻ | 2 | 2 N–O | 3/2 = 1.5 | both N–O bonds equal |
| SO₂ (octet form) | 2 | 2 S–O | 1.5 | both S–O bonds equal |
| NO₃⁻ | 3 | 3 N–O | 4/3 ≈ 1.33 | three equal N–O bonds |
| CO₃²⁻ | 3 | 3 C–O | 4/3 ≈ 1.33 | three equal C–O bonds, longer than in CO₂ (bond order 2) |
| HCOO⁻ (formate) | 2 | 2 C–O | 1.5 | two equal C–O bonds |
| C₆H₆ (benzene) | 2 | 6 C–C | 9/6 = 1.5 | six equal C–C bonds |
When resonance is present, compare bond lengths using bond order: higher bond order means shorter and stronger. For example, the C–O bond length order is CO (bond order 3) < CO₂ (2) < HCOO⁻ (1.5) < CO₃²⁻ (1.33) < CH₃OH (1).
Not every structure is resonance. Moving an atom (for example, moving H from one atom to another) gives a different molecule (an isomer), not a resonance structure. HCN and HNC are isomers, not resonance structures.
Formal charge. When several valid Lewis diagrams are possible, formal charge helps choose the best one (SAP-4.B.2). Formal charge is a bookkeeping charge that assumes each bonding pair is split equally between its two atoms:
V is the number of valence electrons of the free atom, L is the number of lone-pair (nonbonding) electrons on the atom in the structure, and B is the number of bonding electrons around the atom. A quick equivalent form is FC = V − (number of bonds + number of lone-pair electrons).
Two checks:
-
The formal charges in a structure always add up to the overall charge (0 for a molecule, −1 for NO₃⁻, and so on).
-
Formal charge is not the real charge on an atom. Real partial charges depend on electronegativity. Formal charge is a tool for comparing structures.
Rules for choosing the best Lewis diagram.
-
Atoms in period 2 (C, N, O, F) must not exceed an octet. Obey the octet rule wherever possible.
-
Prefer the structure in which formal charges are as close to zero as possible (fewest atoms with nonzero formal charge, and smallest magnitudes).
-
If a negative formal charge is needed, place it on the most electronegative atom.
-
Avoid structures with like formal charges on adjacent atoms.
Worked comparison: CO₂. Two arrangements both give every atom an octet.
| Structure | FC on left O | FC on C | FC on right O | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| O=C=O (2 lone pairs on each O) | 6 − (4 + 2) = 0 | 4 − (0 + 4) = 0 | 0 | best: all zero |
| O≡C–O (1 lone pair on left O, 3 on right O) | 6 − (2 + 3) = +1 | 0 | 6 − (6 + 1) = −1 | worse: separated charges, and + on very electronegative O |
Worked comparison: choosing a skeleton (HCN versus HNC). H–C≡N (one lone pair on N): H 0, C 0, N 0. H–N≡C (one lone pair on C): H 0, N 5 − (0 + 4) = +1, C 4 − (2 + 3) = −1. The atom arrangement H–C–N gives all zero formal charges, consistent with the fact that HCN is the stable molecule.
Expanded octets and formal charge (sulfate, SO₄²⁻). If S forms four single bonds, the formal charges are S +2 and each O −1. If S forms two S=O double bonds and two S–O single bonds (12 electrons around S), the formal charges are S 0, two O 0 and two O −1. Formal charge favours the second structure. Calculations show the real bonding is closer to the octet structure with polar bonds, so either diagram is generally accepted on the AP exam unless the question asks you to choose using formal charge; in that case choose the one with formal charges closer to zero. The CED scoring guidelines for SO₂ accepted octet structures (O=S–O with one lone pair on S) and the expanded structure (O=S=O) alike.
Limitations of the Lewis model (SAP-4.B.3).
-
Odd-electron species such as NO (11 e⁻) and NO₂ (17 e⁻) cannot give every atom an octet; one atom has an unpaired electron.
-
A single Lewis diagram cannot show delocalized electrons; resonance is a patch.
-
Lewis diagrams do not show shape, and they do not explain properties such as the paramagnetism (attraction to a magnet) of O₂, which has two unpaired electrons even though its Lewis diagram O=O shows all electrons paired.
Key equations
Worked examples
Worked example 2.6-A. Nitrate ion, NO₃⁻.
Step 1. Valence electrons: 5 + 3 × 6 + 1 = 24.
Step 2. N central with three single bonds (6 e⁻); each O gets 3 lone pairs (18 e⁻). All 24 used, but N has only 6 electrons, so convert one O lone pair into a N=O bond.
Step 3. The double bond could be to any of the three O atoms, so there are three equivalent resonance structures, each written in brackets with a 1− charge, joined by ↔.
Step 4. Formal charges in one structure: N 5 − (0 + 4) = +1; double-bonded O 6 − (4 + 2) = 0; each single-bonded O 6 − (6 + 1) = −1. Sum: +1 + 0 − 1 − 1 = −1. Correct.
Step 5. Bond order: 4 shared pairs over 3 N–O bonds = 4/3 ≈ 1.33. All three N–O bonds are the same length, shorter than an N–O single bond and longer than an N=O double bond.
Worked example 2.6-B. Dinitrogen monoxide, N₂O (atom order N–N–O). Total valence electrons: 2 × 5 + 6 = 16.
| Structure | FC terminal N | FC central N | FC O |
|---|---|---|---|
| I: N=N=O (2 lone pairs on terminal N, 2 on O) | 5 − (4 + 2) = −1 | 5 − (0 + 4) = +1 | 6 − (4 + 2) = 0 |
| II: N≡N–O (1 lone pair on terminal N, 3 on O) | 5 − (2 + 3) = 0 | +1 | 6 − (6 + 1) = −1 |
| III: N–N≡O (3 lone pairs on terminal N, 1 on O) | 5 − (6 + 1) = −2 | +1 | 6 − (2 + 3) = +1 |
III is worst (largest charges, and + on O). I and II each have one +1 and one −1, but II puts the negative formal charge on O, the most electronegative atom, so II is the major contributor. I is a minor contributor.
Worked example 2.6-C. Thiocyanate ion, SCN⁻ (atom order S–C–N, 16 valence electrons).
| Structure | FC on S | FC on C | FC on N |
|---|---|---|---|
| [S=C=N]⁻, 2 lone pairs on S and on N | 0 | 0 | −1 |
| [S–C≡N]⁻, 3 lone pairs on S, 1 on N | −1 | 0 | 0 |
| [S≡C–N]⁻, 1 lone pair on S, 3 on N | +1 | 0 | −2 |
The third structure is clearly worst. The first places the −1 charge on N, which is more electronegative than S (3.04 vs 2.58), so by the rules it is the best single structure; the second is also a significant contributor.
Unit 2 study guide: exam-style free-response set, worksheet and answers.
Worked example
- Valence electrons: ; one structure has one N=O and two N-O bonds.
- N: ; double-bonded O: ; each single-bonded O: . Sum , the ion's charge.
- Three equivalent resonance structures share 4 bonds over 3 positions: bond order .
- Answer: Formal charges N , O , O , O ; average bond order .
Free-response practice
Write your answer first, then open the solution and mark yourself against it.
FRQ 2.6-1. (Modelled on 2017 AP FRQ Q2(a), choosing between Lewis diagrams of an isomer by formal charge.) Two Lewis diagrams for the molecule cyanic acid with atom order H–O–C–N are proposed.
Structure 1: H–O–C≡N, two lone pairs on O, one lone pair on N.
Structure 2: H–O=C=N, one lone pair on O, two lone pairs on N.
(a) Show that both structures contain the correct number of valence electrons.
(b) Calculate the formal charge on each atom in both structures.
(c) Which structure is the better representation? Justify using formal charges.
Show the solution
(a) Valence electrons: 1 + 6 + 4 + 5 = 16. Structure 1: 5 bonding pairs (H–O, O–C, and three in C≡N) = 10 e⁻, plus 3 lone pairs = 6 e⁻; total 16. Structure 2: 5 bonding pairs (H–O, two in O=C, two in C=N) = 10 e⁻, plus 3 lone pairs = 6 e⁻; total 16. 1 point.
(b) Structure 1: H 0; O 6 − (4 + 2) = 0; C 4 − (0 + 4) = 0; N 5 − (2 + 3) = 0. Structure 2: H 0; O 6 − (2 + 3) = +1; C 0; N 5 − (4 + 2) = −1. 1 point.
(c) Structure 1. All of its formal charges are zero, while Structure 2 has a +1 on O and a −1 on N. Structures with formal charges closer to zero are preferred, and Structure 2 also places a positive formal charge on the most electronegative atom. 1 point.
FRQ 2.6-2. (Modelled on 2016 AP FRQ Q2(e), bond lengths and resonance in a carbon–oxygen ion.) In the formate ion, HCOO⁻, the H atom is bonded to C, and C is bonded to both O atoms. Experiments show the two C–O bonds are the same length, 127 pm.
(a) Draw (describe) Lewis diagrams for HCOO⁻ consistent with this information.
(b) In formic acid, HCOOH, the extra H is bonded to one O atom. Formic acid has two different C–O bond lengths, 120 pm and 134 pm. Assign each length to a bond and explain.
(c) Explain why the C–O bond length in HCOO⁻ falls between the two values in HCOOH.
Show the solution
(a) 18 valence electrons (1 + 4 + 12 + 1). Two resonance structures in brackets with a 1− charge, joined by ↔: in one, C has a single bond to H, a double bond to the first O (two lone pairs) and a single bond to the second O (three lone pairs); in the other, the double and single bonds are swapped. 1 point for correct electron count and valid structure, 1 point for showing both resonance structures.
(b) 120 pm is the C=O double bond; 134 pm is the C–O single bond to the OH oxygen. In HCOOH there is no resonance between the two O atoms (one carries H), so one bond has order 2 and the other order 1; the higher-order bond is shorter. 1 point.
(c) In HCOO⁻ the π electrons are delocalized over both C–O bonds, so each has bond order 1.5, between 1 and 2. Its length is therefore between those of a single and a double bond. 1 point.
Common mistake
Students think a molecule flips back and forth between resonance structures. The molecule has one structure, the hybrid, in which electrons are delocalized; for example, all three N-O bonds in nitrate are identical.
Frequently asked questions
?How do you calculate formal charge quickly?
Formal charge = valence electrons minus (lone-pair electrons + number of bonds). The formal charges in a structure always add up to the overall charge.
?Is formal charge the same as oxidation number?
No. Formal charge assumes bonding electrons are shared equally, while oxidation number assigns them all to the more electronegative atom.
Practice questions on 2.6
- Q1What is the formal charge on nitrogen in ?
- Q2Which statement describes the three N–O bonds in the nitrate ion, ?
- Q3Two Lewis diagrams of are and . Which is better, and why?
- Q4Two Lewis diagrams of each have one atom with a formal charge of −1: in one it is on S, in the other it is on N. Which is preferred?
- Q5Which molecule must be represented by resonance structures?
- Q6In the nitrate ion, NO₃⁻, what are the formal charge on N and the N–O bond order?
- Q7Which species has the longest carbon–oxygen bond?
- Q8Two Lewis diagrams are proposed for N₂O: (I) N=N=O and (II) N≡N–O, each with all atoms having octets. Which statement is correct?
- Q9In the octet Lewis diagram of SO₄²⁻ in which S forms four single bonds, the formal charge on S is
- Q10Experiments show that the two O–O bonds in ozone have the same length. Which statement best explains this?
- Q11Which statement about formal charge is true?
- Q12Two structures of cyanate are possible: (I) [N≡C–O]⁻ with the −1 formal charge on O, and (II) [N=C=O]⁻ with the −1 formal charge on N. Which contributes more, and why?
- Q13Which element forms a hydride with the same shape as ?
- Q14Among possible Lewis structures, the preferred one usually:
- Q15Which is another valid resonance structure of the azide ion, [N=N=N]⁻?
- Q16What is the C–O bond order in the carbonate ion, ?
- Q17In one resonance structure of , what is the formal charge on carbon, and what is the average C–O bond order?
Terms used in this topic
Stuck on a unit? Let us fix it this week.
Book a 30-minute one-to-one session for $20. Bring a test, a homework set or the topic that is not clicking.
Book a session