4.4 Physical and chemical changes
AP Chemistry Unit 4: Chemical Reactions · 1 simulation · 15 practice questions
Updated · Aligned to the AP Chemistry Course and Exam Description
A physical change alters the form or state of a substance without changing its identity, such as melting ice, so only intermolecular forces are overcome or formed. A chemical change breaks and forms chemical bonds and produces new substances, such as . Some processes, like dissolving an ionic salt, involve breaking strong interactions and can be described either way.
Physical or chemical?
Physical: same substance, new form.
Chopping vegetables, shredding paper, melting ice, boiling water. is still .
Chemical: a new substance.
Rotting, burning, rusting, digesting. At the particle level, bonds break and new bonds form: H–H and O=O break, O–H bonds form.
Evidence that a reaction happened.
A new gas, like from .
A solid appears when two solutions mix.
Two clear solutions turn pink.
Energy released by new bonds.
Physical or chemical?
? + → + + . Which observation proves a reaction: bubbles, the total volume, a colorless result, or electrical conductivity?Think, then tap to check
Bubbles: gas is a new substance. Both solutions were already colorless and already conducted.
?Water bubbles at 100 °C. Which gas in the bubbles would support "physical change"?Think, then tap to check
: same substance, new state. or would mean water decomposed, a chemical change.
Study notes
Key concepts
Link the macroscopic change to the bonds (TRA-1.D.1). The particle-level way to classify a change is to ask which attractions are broken or formed.
| Type of process | What is broken or formed | Typical energy involved | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chemical process | Chemical bonds (intramolecular: covalent, ionic, metallic) are broken and new ones are formed | Large (often hundreds of kJ per mole) | Combustion, decomposition of water into H₂ and O₂, neutralisation (new O–H bonds in water), precipitation (new ionic lattice) |
| Physical process | Only intermolecular interactions (London dispersion, dipole–dipole, hydrogen bonding, ion–dipole) change | Smaller (often tens of kJ per mole) | Melting, boiling, condensing, dissolving sugar, mixing liquids |
Example: in H₂O(l) → H₂O(g), hydrogen bonds between molecules are overcome but no O–H bond breaks (physical). In 2H₂O(l) → 2H₂(g) + O₂(g), O–H covalent bonds break and H–H and O=O bonds form (chemical).
Some processes are ambiguous (TRA-1.D.2). Dissolving an ionic solid such as NaCl in water can be argued either way:
-
Argument for chemical: the ionic bonds holding the lattice together are broken, and new ion–dipole interactions between the ions and water form. Bonds (ionic attractions) are broken.
-
Argument for physical: no new substance with a new formula is made. Evaporating the water gives back NaCl with the same composition, and the particles (Na⁺ and Cl⁻) are present before and after.
On the AP exam you will not be asked for "the" right answer for such a case; you will be asked to support a claim with reasoning. A full-credit answer names the interactions broken and formed.
Strength of the attractions tells you about the energy. Breaking covalent bonds usually requires much more energy than overcoming intermolecular forces. For water, about 41 kJ is needed to boil one mole at 100 °C, while about 926 kJ would be needed to break the two O–H bonds in one mole of water molecules (bond enthalpy about 463 kJ/mol each). That is why water boils easily on a stove but does not decompose.
Neutralisation is chemical. When HCl(aq) and NaOH(aq) react, H⁺ and OH⁻ form new O–H covalent bonds in water. class notes Q3 asks this: the change is chemical because O–H bonds form.
Worked examples
Worked example 4.4-A. Classify each process as physical or chemical by identifying the interactions that change: (i) iodine sublimes; (ii) methane burns; (iii) ethanol dissolves in water.
Solution
(i) Physical. Only London dispersion forces between I₂ molecules are overcome; the I–I covalent bond stays intact.
(ii) Chemical. C–H and O=O bonds break; C=O and O–H bonds form, making CO₂ and H₂O.
(iii) Physical. Hydrogen bonds between ethanol molecules and between water molecules are broken, and new hydrogen bonds between ethanol and water form. No covalent bonds inside the molecules break.
Worked example 4.4-B. A student dissolves 150 g of NaOH in water and makes the volume up to 1.00 L. The flask becomes very hot. Make a claim about whether the process is physical or chemical, and support it.
Solution
Either claim earns credit if it is supported correctly. Claim "chemical": the ionic bonds in the solid NaOH lattice are broken, and strong ion–dipole interactions form between Na⁺, OH⁻ and water; the large heat release shows strong new interactions forming. Claim "physical": the Na⁺ and OH⁻ ions are present both before and after; no new substance is formed and evaporating the water gives back NaOH. The best answer recognises that the process has features of both.
Unit 4 study guide: exam-style free-response set, worksheet and answers.
Worked example
- (a) : the substance stays ; only IMFs change.
- (b) Methane and oxygen form and : bonds are broken and formed.
- (c) : a new substance precipitates.
- Answer: (a) physical; (b) chemical; (c) chemical
Free-response practice
Write your answer first, then open the solution and mark yourself against it.
FRQ 4.4-1. The enthalpy change for melting NaCl(s) is about +28 kJ/mol, while the enthalpy change for breaking NaCl(s) into separate gaseous ions, NaCl(s) → Na⁺(g) + Cl⁻(g), is about +787 kJ/mol.
(a) Identify the particles present in liquid NaCl.
(b) Melting is usually called a physical change. Using the numbers above, explain why melting NaCl needs much less energy than separating the ions completely.
(c) A student claims that when NaCl dissolves in water, "ionic bonds are broken, so dissolving must be chemical". Give one piece of evidence that supports the student and one that argues against the claim.
Show the solution
(a) Na⁺ and Cl⁻ ions that can move past each other. (1 point)
(b) In the liquid, each ion is still surrounded closely by oppositely charged ions, so most of the attraction remains; only the regular arrangement is lost. Separating the ions into a gas removes all attractions, which takes far more energy (787 kJ vs 28 kJ). (1 point)
(c) Supports: the ions in the lattice are separated (ionic attractions broken) and new ion–dipole attractions to water form. Against: no new substance is formed; evaporating the water gives back NaCl with the same composition. (1 point each)
Common mistake
Students classify boiling water as a chemical change because a gas forms. The gas is still ; only the intermolecular forces between molecules were overcome, so it is a physical change.
Frequently asked questions
?Is dissolving salt a physical or chemical change?
It is often called physical, but it breaks ionic interactions and forms ion-dipole interactions, so the AP course treats it as a process with features of both.
?Is a phase change ever a chemical change?
No. Melting, freezing, boiling, condensing and sublimation change only the arrangement of particles, not their identity.
Practice questions on 4.4
- Q1Which of these is a chemical change?
- Q2Solutions of and HCl are mixed: . Which observation is evidence that a reaction took place?
- Q3Water in a beaker is heated to 100 °C and bubbles vigorously. Which substance in the bubbles supports the claim that this is a physical change?
- Q4Which observation shows a physical change but not a chemical change?
- Q5Which statement best explains why boiling water is a physical change while electrolysis of water is a chemical change?
- Q6Which process is the best example of one that could reasonably be argued to be either physical or chemical?
- Q7Which change involves breaking covalent bonds?
- Q8Which type of interaction is most directly overcome when liquid ammonia boils?
- Q9What type of change is ?
- Q10Process 1: . Process 2: . Which statement is correct?
- Q11Magnesium burns in air to form MgO. Why is this a chemical change?
- Q12Which is a physical change?
- Q13Which is a chemical change?
- Q14Which change is often described as ambiguous (it can be argued to be either physical or chemical)?
- Q15KOH pellets dissolve in water, releasing heat. How is this best classified?
Terms used in this topic
Stuck on a unit? Let us fix it this week.
Book a 30-minute one-to-one session for $20. Bring a test, a homework set or the topic that is not clicking.
Book a session